How were 64 calves stolen from an Ohio farm in a coordinated overnight heist?

The Heist Details

On the night of May 2-3, 2026, 64 Holstein calves were stolen from a converted turkey barn at a farm in Coldwater, Ohio. The calves belonged to Gaerke Brother Farms but were being cared for by Selhorst Farms at the time of the theft. The operation occurred between 10 p.m. Saturday and 6 a.m. Sunday. The stolen calves were 13 weeks old, freshly weaned, and identifiable by their distinctive black and white or red and white markings. Each calf weighed approximately 250 pounds.

Perpetrator Profile and Equipment

Sheriff Doug Timmerman indicated the theft was highly coordinated and required significant planning. The perpetrators likely loaded a full trailer of cattle, which is why not all available calves were taken. Authorities suspect the thieves were very familiar with handling cattle and possessed specialized equipment necessary for the operation. A van would have been insufficient; the heist required a truck trailer or potentially a semi to transport the animals. The perpetrators would also need the means to care for the calves afterward and an outlet to sell or raise them, suggesting a sophisticated operation with advance planning.

Economic Impact

The 64 stolen calves represent a loss exceeding $100,000, valued at between $1,800 and $2,000 each. Holstein calves are valuable livestock, bred for dairy production. According to Oklahoma State University's research, Holsteins produce an average of 17,408 pounds of milk, 632 pounds of butterfat, and 550 pounds of protein annually, making them highly sought-after in agricultural operations.

Investigation and Response

The Mercer County Sheriff's Office launched an investigation immediately after the theft was reported. As of the latest reports, no suspects have been identified. Authorities are reviewing surveillance footage from nearby locations and have alerted area sale barns about the stolen livestock. Law enforcement is appealing to the public for information and any Ring doorbell or security camera footage that might help identify the perpetrators.