Why YouTube Blocked Direct Sales
YouTube is the world's largest distribution platform but not a distributor itself. For films and TV shows that viewers purchase or rent, YouTube makes deals with aggregators—companies that package, standardize, and deliver content at scale while handling rights clearances, metadata, and formatting. This system was never designed to accommodate creators who already have their own audience, capital, and independence intact.
Markiplier's Rights Dilemma
Markiplier could have signed with existing aggregators to sell Iron Lung on YouTube, but doing so would require ceding certain rights. After self-distributing a $50 million theatrical release, he was unwilling to surrender that control. Instead, he entered what he described as an arduous legal process that required negotiating directly with YouTube CEO Neal Mohan to secure an exception.
The Exception Granted
YouTube ultimately agreed to serve as the exclusive digital home for Iron Lung, marking a rare exception for this particular creator and film. However, Markiplier views this as just one piece of a larger vision for reforming how independent filmmakers access distribution.
Markiplier's Broader Vision
Rather than accepting YouTube's one-off exception, Markiplier plans to become an aggregator himself. His goal is to build a system where any filmmaker could access YouTube distribution without intermediaries, allowing creators to remain on the platform throughout the entire distribution process. He envisions a model where trailers live on YouTube with purchase links, enabling viewers to convert without leaving the platform. 
Answer